Living My Best/Worst Life

Living in envy of the life you thought all your talent, ambition, and hard work would eventually lead to.

Living My Best/Worst Life

Sometimes I look at my brothers’ lives and feel like a huge failure.
That’s uncomfortable to admit, because I have nothing against them or the lives they’ve built. They haven’t done anything wrong by doing well. I don’t wish they had less.

But I look at where they are, then where I am, and wonder what happened. I had talent. I had ambition. I worked hard. There were times when things were going well, when I could see a life taking shape that I was excited about.
So how did I get from there to here?

That’s the question I keep turning over. And to be fair to myself, I wasn’t sitting around with my cello waiting for somebody to discover me.

When I lived in Minneapolis, I was playing a lot. Lugging my case into coffee shops and cramped corner venues, sometimes on my own and sometimes with other musicians. I was meeting people. Other artists started asking me to play on their CDs, tracking cello in drafty living rooms and small studios on songs they’d written.

It was going well. Great, even, at times.

I was building a name for myself. A small one, sure, but people knew my playing and wanted me involved in what they were creating. That meant something to me. So when I catch myself thinking “nothing really happened,” that isn’t true. Things were happening. I had good reasons to believe I was getting somewhere. I knew it took more than talent—you had to know people, master your craft, show up and do the work—and at that point, I was doing all of it.

Which is why, when I look at where I am now, my instinct is still to find a way to blame myself.

But what, exactly, am I blaming myself for?

I can’t blame myself for having chronic illnesses and pain. Knowing that doesn’t stop me from looking backward and wondering what I could have done differently, but the math doesn't work.

Especially about Minneapolis.

What if I’d stayed? Kept playing, kept meeting people, kept getting asked to work on somebody’s music? I had something going there, and I wonder what kind of life I might have built if I’d stayed the course.

Of course, in that version of the story, things keep going well. I don’t picture staying in Minneapolis and getting sick anyway. I picture the possibilities I left behind, and then compare them with the life I actually have.

That’s a comparison my current life is pretty much guaranteed to lose.
And right now, it doesn’t need much help losing. Doctors. Tests. More tests. A referral to another doctor, who refers me to a specialist. I’m putting plenty of effort into my life; I’d just like some of that effort to lead somewhere besides another waiting room. Meanwhile, I’m trying to make disability cover everything, figuring out what I can afford and what I’ll have to go without. It sucks.

“Why me?” goes through my head constantly. I know it gets me nowhere, but knowing a question is useless doesn’t keep you from asking it. And yes, I know I can only live in the now. I can’t go back to Minneapolis and find out what would have happened, just like I can’t jump ahead to a time when things might be easier. But being told to live in the present is a little less comforting when you’re spending so much of it in a clinic gown.

I want more of my day to belong to something I actually care about: playing music, creating something, having a conversation that doesn’t involve explaining what hurts. I don’t know how much of that I can get back right now, but I miss it.
Maybe missing it is why I’m so hard on myself. I remember what it felt like to be playing, collaborating, and getting asked to contribute. I wanted more of that. I still do.

Those years count. The small venues count. Being asked to play on somebody’s recording counts. I was doing something I loved, and other people wanted me there. I think I expected it to lead to something bigger, and because it didn’t, I’ve somehow worked backward and dismissed what actually happened.

I can regret leaving Minneapolis. I can wonder whether I missed opportunities or made choices I’d make differently now. There are probably things I could have done better, and I’m comfortable admitting that. What I can’t do is pretend I know how the other version would have turned out. Staying wouldn’t have guaranteed a career, financial security, or a healthy body. It’s just easy to forget that when I’m imagining it from here.

And my brothers’ lives can’t answer those questions for me, either. They’re living their lives. I’m the one turning the comparison into a verdict.

Living my best life? No. I’m not going to pretend I’m happy with how things are right now. I want less pain. Fewer appointments. Enough money to breathe a little. More room for music and art and whatever else I still want to do.

But when I say I’m a huge failure, I’m leaving an awful lot out—including the guy in Minneapolis who was building something. Those years happened. That work mattered. The fact that it didn’t become everything I hoped for doesn’t erase it.
I can be disappointed with where I am without dismissing everything it took to get here. I understand that when I write it down; remembering it when I look at somebody else’s life is a little harder.

I’d like to stop turning every comparison into another reason to blame myself. I suspect it’ll take more than writing a blog post and declaring myself cured.

Especially since I’ll probably need a referral for that.